Otto Insurance vs GEICO
Products, Ratings, & Customer Service Comparison (2024)
Get quotes from verified agents easily.
Last Updated: January 15, 2024
Deciding on the right insurance company to trust with your valuable assets is no easy task. With numerous providers out there, it can be difficult to know where to start. That’s why we have this comparison blog that will help decide between two prominent providers – Otto and GEICO. This Otto Insurance vs GEICO Insurance comparison is based on GEICO reviews 2023 and Otto Insurance reviews 2023.
Otto Insurance has a community of over 10 million customers in its short journey within a short span of time. GEICO is part of the $32 billion Berkshire Hathaway empire and has over 16 million customers (nearly the population of New York) for auto insurance alone. As we compare these two companies, we’ll examine their car, home, and life insurance policies, and provide you with all the key information you need.
- A new player in insurance
- Founded in 2018
- Popular for car and pet insurance
- Easy-to-use online platform
- Ratings and accreditations not available yet
- Private company
- An old-time insurance giant
- Founded in 1936
- Specialty in car insurance
- Extensive online platform
- Excellent ratings and accreditations
- Public company
Otto Insurance vs. GEICO: Products
|Travel Trailer Insurance
|Mobile Home Insurance
|Offroad Vehicles and ATVs
*NA: Otto’s official website does not mention if they provide the particular insurance, but since it mentions the broad category such as Auto Insurance and offers quotes from multiple carriers, it may provide other coverages.
A key difference between GEICO and Otto is their range of products. While GEICO offers a wide range of insurance coverages, Otto Insurance has only specified a few broad coverages such as Auto, Home, Pets, Life, and Commercial.
Car Insurance Comparison
The major type of insurance that Otto and GEICO are competing for is car insurance.
GEICO boasts an 85-year history in providing car insurance, and in helping you get an affordable policy. They also have a 97% customer satisfaction rating based on an independent study by Alan Newman Research in 2022. Furthermore, there are GEICO insurance agents, their very own local agents that can guide you through every mile.
Otto car insurance, on the other hand, claims itself to be an unbiased website where you can view the best car insurance rates in your ZIP code. So, if you are looking to compare, you can try out their car insurance calculator and check your options.
GEICO Car Insurance Highlights
- Online quotes
- No comparison- quotes directly from GEICO
- $500+ average annual savings
- Military, federal employee and corporate group discounts
- Mechanical breakdown insurance (MBI)
- Better customer service reputation
- 24/7 roadside assistance
Otto Car Insurance Highlights
- Online quotes in minutes
- Compare quotes from top providers
- $500+ per year savings based on their survey
- Free for insurance buyers
Auto insurance carriers you can access through Otto
- Liberty Mutual
- American Family
When it comes to other policies from both the companies, their home insurance is comparable.
You can get a wide range of discounts on GEICO homeowners insurance like multi-policy discount and discounts on installing smoke detectors, fire extinguishers, and home security systems. GEICO also offers added coverage like mobile home and condo insurance. Other key features like getting online quotes, and saving are like its car insurance highlights. However, something to note is that GEICO secures home insurance policies from the GEICO Insurance Agency which places business with home insurance companies like:
- American Modern
- Citizens Property Insurance Corp.
- The Hartford
- First Insurance Company of Hawaii
- Lemonade Insurance Company
- Foremost Property and Casualty Insurance Company
- Liberty Mutual
- SageSure Insurance
- TAPCO Underwriters Inc, and many other
Likewise, through Otto Insurance, you can get quotes from top home insurance companies like Nationwide, Esurance, AAA Insurance, Farmers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, and American Family Insurance.
In this regard, GEICO’s home insurance is very similar to Otto home insurance, as both don’t write the policies directly but help insurance buyers secure it.
However, Otto has not disclosed a lot of information like available discounts or added features for their home insurance.
A key highlight of Otto life insurance is that you can get quotes without a medical exam. So, if you are looking to save time while getting life insurance, a no-exam policy is a good option. Similarly, no up-front payment or CC is required for most instant activations as per Otto’s website.
In the case of GEICO, the GEICO Insurance Agency, LLC and its partners team up to write life insurance policies for you. If you choose to get a life insurance quote online from GEICO, you will be directed to the website of Life Quotes, Inc or Ladder Insurance Services, LLC. The GEICO Insurance Agency, LLC has many other affiliated and non-affiliated insurance companies that write the policies.
|Better Business Bureau
|A+ (But not accredited)
|Standard & Poor's (S&P)
As Otto is relatively new, it has not been rated or accredited by third-party market watchdogs like BBB, A.M. Best or S&P.
On the other hand, while GEICO has received high financial ratings, it has not been accredited by the BBB. The rating is based on BBB’s judgement of how well the carrier will handle customer complaints and settle them, while the accreditation is gained based on the registered complaints on BBB that are handled and closed by the company.
|Website, Mobile app, Phone, Local GEICO agents
|Website, Mobile app, Phone
|Yes (1 tap bill pay, digital ID cards, claims filing, and many more)
Canceling an Insurance Policy: GEICO and Otto
An insurance policy can generally be canceled at any time, although the specific rules and requirements may vary depending on the insurance provider and policy type. Individuals typically have the flexibility to cancel their insurance policy when they no longer need coverage or find a more suitable alternative. However, it is important to carefully review the terms and conditions of the policy to understand any potential fees or penalties associated with cancellation.
Some insurance policies may have a minimum contract period, during which cancellation may result in additional charges. Moreover, it is advisable to check whether there are any specific procedures or notice requirements outlined by the insurance provider for cancellation. By adhering to the prescribed guidelines, policyholders can ensure a smooth and hassle-free cancellation process.
Cancel GEICO Insurance:
GEICO insurance policy cancellation is a simple procedure. Start by reviewing the cancellation policy in your insurance’s terms and conditions. Contact GEICO’s customer service at (800) 841-3005 and inform them of your decision to cancel. Provide your policy details and the desired effective date for cancellation. Make sure to settle any outstanding payments before proceeding. For your records, request written confirmation of the cancellation via email.
Here is a step-by-step guide to canceling your GEICO insurance policy
Cancel Otto Insurance:
Unlike many other insurance providers, canceling your Otto insurance policy is a simple process. Begin by thoroughly reviewing your policy and familiarizing yourself with the cancellation terms. Contact Otto’s customer service at (888) 804-5641 to start the cancellation process. Clearly communicate your cancellation request and provide the necessary policy details, including your policy number and other required information. Mention the desired effective date for the cancellation to take effect.
Additionally, ensure all outstanding payments are settled according to Otto’s instructions. As an added step, request written confirmation of the cancellation from Otto. This confirmation will serve as valuable documentation for your reference, providing proof of the successful cancellation of your Otto insurance policy.
Remember, it’s important to familiarize yourself with the specific cancellation policies and procedures of GEICO or Otto and to follow their guidelines to ensure a successful cancellation of your insurance policy.
Otto Insurance vs. GEICO: Which Company is Best for You?
Otto Insurance is a relatively new player in the insurance market that offers insurance coverage to customers across the United States. With a strong emphasis on technology and customer experience, Otto aims to simplify the insurance process and make it more accessible for everyone. Overall, they act like an insurance carrier search engine as per your location and let you compare the options.
GEICO mainly focuses on providing affordable car insurance nationwide, and provides other policies through GEICO Insurance Agency, LLC and its affiliated and non-affiliated partners. With a market share of 13.76%, it is the second-largest auto insurer in the U.S.
Here, as we compare Otto Insurance vs GEICO, the exceptional financial strength of GEICO will help you be assured that they have the resources to pay your claims. However, if you are getting policies other than car insurance, then you may not be getting them directly from GEICO as it writes other policies like home and life through its partners. Otto Insurance has the upper hand in this matter, as although they do not write the policy, they still let you compare and choose for yourself.
Likewise, in case of online support both the companies have it to access quotes and make claims, but GEICO has another superior customer service method that Otto lacks, which is their mobile app. You can also reach GEICO through their live chat, which again Otto does not have.
All in all, GEICO is the safe choice if you are going for an established insurance company with plenty of information available online. Otto Insurance is also a viable site to compare carriers and agencies in your locality and save some bucks, but limited online information is a drawback.
Here are some other carriers you might like to compare:
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is GEICO less expensive?
Geico is cheaper than other carriers because it sells car insurance directly to you and offers many discounts. Furthermore, the company frequently advertises its commitment to offer the most affordable insurance for you.
How much does Otto Insurance cost?
As an insurance buyer, you can use Otto Insurance to get quotes for free.
How is Otto insurance vs. GEICO Insurance?
Otto insurance and GEICO offer some comparable features and policies. However, the main difference between them is that GEICO offers insurance directly as well as through the GEICO Insurance Agency, LLC, but Otto does not write insurance and only provides the feature of comparing quotes from other companies. You may read the full comparison on Agency Height.
Find a Local Insurance Agent Near You
Get quotes from verified agents easily.