Goosehead vs. Renegade Insurance: Which is Better for Agents?
Goosehead insurance franchise and Renegade Insurance’s (formerly Covered by SAGE) plug-and-play model are two ways for captive agents to transform into independent agents in the insurance market. Let’s take a look at how these two compare to each other. We will review Goosehead insurance franchise and Renegade Insurance, seeing how they stack up against one another in terms of insurance franchise fees, models, and more.
Independent insurance agency models are continuously changing as a result of large competition and diverse businesses vying for the same pool of clients.
In this age, you can’t succeed just by doing things the old way. You also need a robust support system to help you genuinely grow yourself and your book of business. Multiple agency models exist, but agents don’t always know what will help them best.
Here we’ll be taking a look at two such agency ownership opportunities, namely Goosehead and Renegade Insurance. They share a few similarities, but a lot more differences.
In this blog
Who is Goosehead?
Goosehead is an insurance agency that operates a franchise model. It works on a “you sell, we service” model and, on paper, allows agents to commit fully to sales.
How do Goosehead agents make money?
Goosehead agents work on a commission split basis. They get a percentage of the commission earned for each policy that they write.
Agents make 80% commission on new policies, and 50% commission on renewals.
How does the Goosehead insurance franchise make money?
Goosehead operates a franchise model and charges an upfront insurance franchise fee that can range from $27,500 to $66,000, depending upon the state of the outlet.
A total starting investment of $60,000 to $128,000 is required, and a schedule of additional out of pocket fees charged to agents are detailed in the contract. These include:
- A marketing contribution of 2% of gross revenue.
- Training fees of up to $400 per day.
- Monthly technology fees that amounts to $325 for the first user, and $225 for each additional user.
- Transfer fees of 15% to 100% of the initial franchise fee.
- Variable on-demand attorney fees.
- $500 if you choose to relocate your outlet, and many more.
All of these fees can make running a franchise financially draining.
On top of these costs, they also take a minimum royalty of $1,000 that agents need to pay per month even if they make no sales.
How wide is Goosehead’s market?
Goosehead is appointed with over 80 carriers nationally, and as such, has a vast range of choices to present to potential clients. However, they only focus on personal lines like home, auto, and renters, which severely limits the target market for agents.
A non-compete clause in the contract also doesn’t allow agents to seek appointments with additional P&C agencies or carriers. Therefore, growth-minded agents cannot expand into commercial lines as long as they work with Goosehead. Online Goosehead insurance franchise reviews show that the points mentioned above are the biggest issues agents have with Goosehead.
Who is Renegade Insurance?
Renegade Insurance are newcomers to the insurance industry. At the time of writing, they operate only out of Georgia, with plans to expand throughout the east coast. They’re backed by investors who have built category-defining companies, and believe that disruption through market-leading technology will ultimately allow insurance agents to “be their best selves”.
Unlike Goose head, Renegade Insurance does not operate a franchise model. They’re an independent insurance brokerage platform. They offer a “you sell, we service” model to their agents, but that is just the start of what they’re trying to do.
How do Renegade Insurance agents make money?
Renegade Insurance agents also make money from commissions. Their rates are similar to Goosehead’s, with agents receiving from 80% to 95% commission (depending upon premium value) on new business and 50% commission on renewals for personal lines.
Unlike Goosehead, Renegade Insurance also has a 60-40 split on new business and 40-60 on renewals for commercial lines. Additionally, Renegade Insurance also has options for agents who would like to sell life or health policies, allowing agents to cross-sell all insurance lines of business.
How does Renegade Insurance make money?
Since Renegade Insurance does not operate on a franchise model, there’s no franchise fees or marketing costs that other franchisors charge. Moreover, Renegade Insurance has developed proprietary technology that their agents can use free-of-cost. Agents will have to pay no onboarding fee but only a $100 per month amount.
Coupled with a no retail outlet requirement, agents can virtually start an agency of their own with no retail investment. Ultimately, Renegade Insurance only earns from the commission splits and onboarding fees, tying their success with the success of the agent.
How wide is Renegade Insurance’s market?
At the time of writing, is appointed with over 35 carriers, with more in the pipeline. Agents have wide market access. However unlike Goosehead, also allows agents to sell commercial lines, life, and health policies.
How do they compare?
Goosehead insurance franchise started as an extension of a traditional agency. As such, they have an internal corporate agency that competes directly with its franchisees.
Their “disruptive” technology is simply Salesforce. While this is a powerful platform, it can also be inadequate at times. The growth they experienced in the earlier stages of the company stagnated the need for innovation.
On the other hand, Renegade Insurance started as a technology company. They developed a proprietary plug-and-play technology that is easy to use and free for their agents.
Both companies have similarities, such as remote servicing teams, quoting from multiple carriers, and a lucrative commission split. But these businesses started with radically different goals, and as such, their approach to operating an insurance agency is markedly different.
Goosehead and Renegade Insurance both offer guaranteed buyouts. However, Goosehead imposes several restrictions and fees on the new buyer, reducing the ultimate value of what the franchisee can get. Online reviews for Goosehead insurance franchise aren’t the most complimentary either.
On the other hand, Renegade Insurance provides a buyout of a multiple of the value of the book of business with no strings attached.
In a nutshell
Which should you choose?
Goosehead’s model was revolutionary for a time when captive agencies were dominating markets. They disrupted the industry and were successful. However, a franchise model presents numerous challenges and financial obligations to the franchisee, not to mention a hefty Goosehead insurance franchise fee.
Renegade Insurance is looking to revolutionize the market today. They allow agents to run their agencies with no cost or retail requirements, understanding that agents must be enabled to entirely focus on what they’re good at: Selling.
For agents looking to grow and test their mettle, or even agents looking to take advantage and get a piece of the market, Renegade Insurance is clearly the better choice.
Are you interested in what our affiliated agents are up to? Find out via our agent directory!
Has this article been helpful to you? Leave a comment below and share your thoughts with us.