Last Updated: August 18, 2022

Secrets Of The Best Auto Insurance Companies

TLTR: This article discusses some qualities that you should look for to identify the best auto insurance companies. Additionally, this article also covers the top 10 auto insurance companies in the U.S. and how you can get a lower rate on auto insurance premiums.   

According to IBIS World, the market size for auto insurance in 2021 has reached $311 billion. There are thousands of auto insurance companies in the U.S. When you are planning to shop for car insurance, you are likely to find many options which can be confusing. 

Connect With The Best Insurance Agents Near You

Contact a local agent online to help you with your insurance needs.

In this blog

An auto insurance company is essentially a company that provides policies for your car or other types of vehicles. These policies are generally sold by any company that deals with property and casualty insurance.  

As a car owner, we know that you only want what’s best for your car. All insurers claim to be the best but there are some distinct qualities that make the best auto insurance companies. Being able to identify the good companies from the bad ones takes a lot of research as well as experience. But don’t worry, our industry experts have you covered! 

Qualities of Best Auto Insurance Companies

Insurance companies have a lot of pressure to be consistent in their services and be trustworthy. They need to stay committed for the long term because it takes time, effort, and resources in order for an insurance company to become successful. Here are some must have qualities of best auto insurance companies: 


A good insurer is committed to its customers and stays true to its mission. They are dedicated, reliable as well as dependable. It’s important for insurance companies to have credibility. Here are some questions you can ask to determine if an insurance company is credible:  

  • What is the company’s reputation in the industry? 
  • Does the company have a good claim record? 
  • Is the company consistent with their partners?  
  • Are they capable of delivering everything they promised? 
  • How long has the company been around? 
  • Do they understand all the nuances that follow with owning a car? 

By asking these questions, you can determine what the company is like and if it falls under the category of best auto insurance companies.  

Financial Condition 

One of the main reasons you want to purchase auto insurance is for your own peace of mind. When looking into an insurer, it is extremely important to look at their financial condition.  

In the unfortunate situation that you have a car accident or need assistance regarding your insurance and need your company’s support, they should be there for you as much as possible so that all of your attention can remain on dealing with the issue that arises. 

Again, to check how the company is performing financially, check their claim pay-out time. You can also try to see who their insurance underwriters are. Things like these can help you have an insight into how you will be treated in a situation where you may need their help. 

Connect With The Best Insurance Agents Near You

Contact a local agent online to help you with your insurance needs.

Customer Service 

How many times have you checked online reviews of a product you want to buy and ended up buying that product because of its amazing reviews? We are guessing at least a couple of times if not more. 

According to Doxee, customer reviews help consumers make informed decisions about the products that they want to buy. An insurance company that has good customer service is likely to have good customer reviews.  

When you are looking to buy auto insurance, make sure you try to find out how their existing customers feel like about the company. 

A good insurer should be able to provide services 24/7, multilingually, and globally. They need an extensive network of auto selling companies as well as the ability to accept different modes of payments for their customers’ convenience. 


The leading insurance companies constantly check in with their customers to ensure they are meeting the current needs of expatriates. The products evolve based on what is needed for a better lifestyle and living experience.  

To meet such standards, the best auto insurance companies provide a myriad of customization options for their clients.  

For example, if you are a young driver and are on a tight budget, then your insurance provider should be able to offer you collision, bodily injury, and property damage insurance coverage at a reasonable rate. They should try to sell you a standard car insurance coverage that has more things that you require or can pay for. 

Price Negotiation 

Many times, insurance companies offer different rates to different client base. The reason behind this is so each client gets a good value for the money they invest in their coverage. Find out which client demographic you fit in and try to get a car insurance quote accordingly.  

Additionally, it is possible to get a cheap full coverage insurance at a reasonable price range. You will definitely need to shop around and compare prices. That way you will be much better at negotiating the prices when it comes to buying auto insurance.  


The process of selecting which insurance is suitable for you and your loved ones can be extremely demanding. It’s important that insurers are as clear as possible in their communication by explaining benefits clearly.  

Using standard terminologies to make things easier to understand, and keeping customers informed on the rationale behind premium inflation is also equally important.  

Additionally, insurance contracts often come with industry jargons that an industry outsider may not understand. A good insurance company will have their policies written in simple language.  

Make sure that your contracts don’t have loopholes and covey a clear message.  

Fair Claims Processing 

If you’ve never had to file a claim, it might not seem like claims processing is important. But when you do need your insurance coverage, having everything processed quickly and efficiently makes all the difference in the world.  

When it comes to car insurance, a good company will be able to process simple damage claims quickly. They automate this whole process and most of the claim can be completed online.  

Once you take your car for repair work at a mechanic or body shop, they’ll enter all relevant information on their website where you receive payment once an estimate is approved. 


Connect With The Best Insurance Agents Near You

Contact a local agent online to help you with your insurance needs.

Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies In USA

If you are someone who has gone online to look up best auto insurance companies, you probably found multiple long lists of insurance companies. After looking up lists from the likes of Forbes and other niche sites like Nerd Wallet we decided to also do our own research.

We went through all the lists we could find for you and here are our top picks:

Company Best For
Amica Best Prices
State Farm Best Claim Filling Process
Renegade Insurance Best Overall
USAA Best Service For Veterans, Military and Their Immediate Family Member
Travelers Best Customer Satisfaction Review
Geico Best For People Who Have Poor Credit
Progressive Best For Bundling Insurance
Allstate Best For Customer Service And Claim Process
American Family Best For Client Retention
Auto Owners Insurance Best For Collision Coverage

How Can I Get an Auto Insurance Company to Lower My Premium Rates

People often have the misconception of correlating best with expensive. If you are buying insurance from the best auto insurance companies, you can still get a lower premium rate. Here is how you can do it:  

  • Buy multiple insurance policies if you can. 
  • Show customer loyalty. 
  • If you have more than one vehicle, insure them in the same policy. 
  • Be a good driver, invest in defensive driving courses. 
  • If you are a student, try to find companies that offer student discounts. 
  • If you are someone over the age of 55, try to find companies that offer senior citizen discounts. 
  • Try paying your full premium cost up-front. 
  • Getting a family car insurance plan is also quite cost-effective. See if your family is eligible for that. 



It’s hard to say which is “the best” auto insurance company or what kind of coverage has been the most popular in the past decade. Trends among different companies have changed so often that they’re impossible to keep track of, especially considering each business needs a number of years between updates so their client base can grow.

The best insurance company for you will depend on a few factors: your individual situation and what kind of policy you look for. The first thing to look at is rates–sometimes one company’s premiums are low because they don’t offer certain perks like non-owner car insurance, roadside assistance, travel insurance, etc.

Before making your final decision about driving with any particular company it may be worth considering if your goals as an insured align with their goals as an insurer.

Having trouble figuring out which auto company to buy insurance from? Let us help you find trusty insurance carriers. Get in touch with an agent to start your insurance process today!

Was this blog helpful? Let us know in the comments below.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Does It Matter Which Car Insurance Company You Use?

It sure can. However, it’s hard to figure out which one you should choose. That’s why the best auto insurance companies are some of the most important things for drivers to look out for. Luckily, they’re not too hard to find. 

It just requires an internet connection and a bit of patience.  And then you’ll be able to rank them by quality or price or anything else that matters to you before choosing which company is best for you. 

What Is the Best Type of Coverage for My Car?

There is no set answer for this question. Coverages depend on who you are as a person and also the kind of car you drive.  

The best type of coverage for your car is whatever keeps you happy and safe. The diversity of car insurance companies competing against each other means that almost any preference or need can be accommodated at a bargain price.

Does My Car Insurance Cover Third Party Liability Claims?

This is not clear-cut—it depends on the way in which your insurer defines third-party liability. If your insurance contract states that you are covered for all incidents, then yes. If your insurer only covers bodily injury to yourself or others in your vehicle, then no. 

Chances are when you talk to your insurance provider over call, they might omit this vital detail when you voice coverage inquiries. So, it’s important to read the fine print before signing up for any policy. 

However, it is important to note that if your auto insurer does cover third party liability claims, there will be certain limitations.

How Can I Customize My Car Insurance Policy?

In order to customize your car insurance policy, firstly you will need to figure out how much coverage you need and whether there are any limits to your current policy. Then, research the level of coverage that you want, and then figure out your costs for that plan. 

Thirdly, call up your insurance company to find out what type of discounts they offer. Make sure you end up saving more money. Then, decide if this is the right policy for you by considering if it covers everything well. If not, talk with agents until someone can answer all of your questions well enough to make a decision on an insurance policy without uncertainty or concern about safety or coverage. 

Lastly, considering purchasing a bundle home and auto insurance policy.

Connect With The Best Insurance Agents Near You

Contact a local agent online to help you with your insurance needs.

Related Articles

Leads for insurance

3 Simple Ways to Leverage Networking to Generate Leads for Insurance in 2021

how to become an independent insurance agent

How to Become an Independent Insurance Agent

A Cheat Sheet

Independant Insurance Agent 1

Insurance Claim Process

Helping Clients is The Best Way to Retain Customers and Gain Referrals

Multiple Coverage Options at Your Fingertips

Choose from various options and select the policy that best suits your requirements.